You are currently viewing Tracfone vs Cricket Compared: Which is Better?

Tracfone vs Cricket Compared: Which is Better?

In light of the technological advances all over the world, it is a no-brainer that cell phones play a huge role in our lives. We use them to communicate, organize schedules, take pictures, share stuff on the internet, and even work. Due to the reliance on phones, we are paying more for service, and it is no surprise seeing people spending lots of money every month for their telephone bills.

Most of us are in a constant quest for a perfect cellphone plan that will suit our specific needs. This is vital since some of us are heavy voice call users; others are heavy internet users, and others strike a balance between the two. If you spend a lot on calls, you would be best served by a plan that is good on voice provisions. The same applies to those who spend more time on the internet.

The major carrier brands, AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile, US Cellular, and Verizon Wireless, are the dominant players in the telecommunications niche in America. Many seem inclined to them, but other choices are available to you if you want a bargain and perhaps value for money.

Most of these subsidiary networks are called Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs). They have not invested in their network equipment but instead ride on the primary network carriers, something that enables them to offer top quality services at a subsidized cost.

In light of such arrangements, these major network providers have their low-cost brands. These brands are essentially the MVNOs, and notable examples are Cricket Wireless that is run by AT$T, Virgin and Boost run by Sprint, and Metro run by T-Mobile, just to mention a few. These low-cost brands have become popular in recent years, owing to the friendly prices.

When reviewing some popular network providers, if you are looking for one, it helps to assess them based on a couple of factors. This is because there is no fixed network provider that can be dubbed as the best. One man’s meat is another man’s poison, and what is suitable for someone else might not suit you.

Some key things to look at when comparing them are;

  • How much do you want to spend?
  • Which phones work with the network?
  • How is their customer service?

In this piece, we will break down TracFone and Cricket to try and help you pick one that suits your needs between the two. These are low-cost carriers that are gaining popularity, and it is essential to see what they have to offer before leaping. Read on;

Bottom Line Up Front Summary: If you live in an urban area, TracFone presents a good value because it uses the best available cell networks. TracFone is also great if you (or your loved one) only makes periodic calls. A better solution for higher data usage (think other things beside calling, like text, browsing, music) is to go with one the Cricket Plans here. Cricket is a part of the AT&T network, too, so if your area has good AT&T coverage OR you live in a rural area, Cricket tends to have better service than TracFone.

Main Differences Between TracFone vs Cricket

The main differences between TracFone vs Cricket are:

  • TracFone is an MVNO that relies on five major carriers whereas, Cricket is a subsidiary of AT&T that relies on its network infrastructure
  • TracFone is suitable for people who want to text and make calls periodically whereas, Cricket is ideal for those with low data usage but still need good network coverage
  • TracFone offers no unlimited plan whereas, Cricket has such plans for those that do not want limits on their usage.

What is TracFone?

trackfone logo

TracFone Wireless is one of the first entries in the prepaid, no-contract cellular phone niche. It was set up back in 1996 with the name TracFone. At this time, no-contract plans were a far cry. However, TracFone has grown over the years to emerge as one of the dominant players in the no-contract phone market.

It has established itself as one of the top five telecommunications service providers in the United States with over 26 million customers under all their umbrella brands. TracFone runs several brands apart from the flagship one such as TracFone, StraightTalk Simple Mobile, and Total Wireless, among others. They are continually looking to acquire newer brands in a bid to increase their dominance in the mobile phone industry, a move that is popular with most major players.

TracFone has been touted as a brand that is focused on serving light to moderate cell phone users. Their plans are comparatively cheap and offer excellent value.

What is Cricket Wireless?

cricket wireless

Cricket Wireless is a wholly-owned subsidiary of AT&T Inc. It provides wireless services to over 10 million subscribers in the United States. It started in March 1999 as Leap Wireless International. AT&T moved to acquire this company in March 2014 and merged it with another company to form the present Cricket Wireless.

It is equally a low-cost service provider that offers top quality AT&T services with the same great coverage but at a fraction of the cost. It is fantastic to leverage the power of top-notch equipment provided by a primary carrier such as AT&T, but at a fraction of the cost, you should expect to take a few compromises. We will dive more into details and help you decide if Cricket is the perfect option for you.

TracFone Plans Pricing

TracFone offers its services based on a ‘no contract’ basis. The plans are either ‘Smartphone Only’ or ‘Basic phone.’ The plans are no contract, prepaid ones that span from 30,60,90, and one-year increments.

If you buy a particular plan, say one that lasts 60 days, you won’t have to pay for one again until you exhaust all your resources and need additional ones. If the time elapses, you can carry over your current resources only if you purchase a new plan before the current one expires.

The TracFone plans page can easily overwhelm you with the plethora of plans and prices, but we will break them down here to give you an idea of what suits you.

Basic Phone Plans

Plan Length Features Cost
30 minutes 30 days 30 minutes voice, text, and web $9.99
60 minutes 90 days 60 minutes of talk, text, and web $19.99
120 minutes 90 days 120 minutes of talk, text, and web $29.99
200 minutes 90 days 200 minutes of talk, text, and web $39.99
450 minutes 90 days 450 minutes of talk, text, and web $79.99
400 minutes 365 days 400 minutes of talk, text, and web $99.99
1000 minutes 365 days 400 minutes of talk, text, and web $159.99
1500 minutes 365 days 1,500 minutes of talk, text, and web $199.99

As seen from the table, the phone plans start at $9.99 per month and go to $199.99 for the 365-day plans. One advantage of the high-end plans is that you only incur a one-off fee that allows you to use the resources for the entire year or until they are depleted.

One of the obvious downsides of the basic plans offered by TracFone is that there is no provision for those who want no cap on the resources, essentially, unlimited voice and text plans. Most competitors have started to offer these plans, and it is something that they need to work on.

Smartphone-only plans

Plan Length Features Cost
500MB 30 days 200 minutes, 500 texts, 500 MB data $15
1.0GB 30 days 300 minutes, 1,000 texts, 1GB data $20
500MB 60 days 500 minutes talk, 1,000 texts, 500 MB data $25
1.0GB 60 days 750 minutes, 1,000 texts, 1GB data $35
1.5GB 90 days 750 minutes, 1,000 texts, 1.5GB data $45
2.0GB 90 days 750 minutes, 1,500 texts, 2.0GB data $50
1.5GB 365 days 1,500 minutes, 1,500 texts, 1.5GB data $125

These plans offered by TracFone cost a little bit higher as they start at around $15 per month. Their major downside is evident here as they do not provide unlimited voice and text, with the best plan capping them at 1,500 minutes and text, intended to go for 365 days.

The data provisions are also suitable for people who do basic browsing now and then, but not those who want to stream videos and download heavy applications. If you are a heavy data user, you are better off looking at competitors’ options that offer unlimited data and minutes, such as MetroPCS and Cricket.

Supplementary services

TracFone provides a couple of other additional services, such as international service, minutes, and data bundles. For instance, they have a global calling card, a 500-minute calling card, a 1 GB calling card, and a text card all going for $10. The prices of their supplementary plans are fair compared to the regular ones and they still offer a smooth transition to a higher tier if you want to upgrade.

Their auto-refill discount is also notable, and it allows consistent users to save a few dollars. This service applies when you use more than is allocated for that plan before the end of the stipulated period. Here, you might be forced to buy a new plan before the end of the period, and TracFone will give you a small discount.

Cricket Plans Pricing

Cricket Wireless plans are available in several tiers. This way, you can easily select one that meets your budget and requirements.

This is one of the best features of their service.

Plan Monthly cost Peak Bandwidth Limitation
5 GB $30 5G (up to 12 Mbps) Data speed reduced after 5 GB limit
10 GB $40 5G LTE (up to 12 Mbps) Data speed reduced after 10 GB limit
Unlimited $55 5G (up to 3 Mbps) Slow speeds for periods where the network is congested
Unlimited with 15 GB Mobile Hotspot $60 5G (up to 12 Mbps) Slow speeds after 15 GB limit


Except for the 5GB plan, you pay $5 less if you use AutoPay. If you are a very light data user, the Cricket low-cost plans stand out as the best option for you.

Out of these data plans, the best value one is perhaps the Unlimited with 15 GB mobile Hotspot as you get more for less. However, note that the data speeds are capped after the 15 GB limit, and from here, you can only enjoy basic browsing.

Cricket has a wide variety of family plans if you wish to include more people into it.

Coverage and Performance

cricket devices

TracFone Coverage

Compared to the other MVNOs, TracFone has a massive advantage in regards to network coverage and performance. This is because its network rides on five service providers.

This way, their coverage is more widespread and you expect to get a good network in many states. However, it is crucial to understand that TracFone pays to use these network carriers, and they might not have all the resources at their disposal. This way, they might just pick one for you depending on your location and other factors.

MVNOs lease space on network towers meaning that they are not the priority on the network. This way, it is expected that the carrier leasing out their infrastructure will prioritize their own services as opposed to those of the MVNO leasing their equipment.

This can compromise the quality of services received by customers, especially when you compare them to what is received by the ones that get their services from the leading carriers. However, it is nothing personal that applies to TracFone only. It is the price of opting for cheaper services offered by low-cost carriers.

Cricket Coverage

Cricket Wireless has superior coverage compared to most of the MVNO service providers. It is a subsidiary of AT&T, meaning that you get the benefit of nationwide coverage. Since it is the same with AT&T, users enjoy the benefits of signing up with a major network carrier while still under an MVNO. This gives them the best of both since they can access top quality services at a fraction of the cost.

Customer Service

TracFone Customer Service

If you go online, you will find TracFone being reviewed poorly by a significant number of people. This is obviously a concern as it indicates that there are some aspects of their service that could have been better. Most bad reviews show unhelpful customer service reps, and others allude to the poor quality and skills of the people at the customer service desks.

However, do not be quick to take marks away from TracFone as it has become a norm for the Telecom industry to offer poor customer service.  If you need to contact them, you can do so through chat, Twitter, and Facebook through the links on their customer service page.

Cricket Customer Service

Compared to most of the MVNOs, Cricket’s customer service is among the best. Well, the bar is so low in the Telecommunications industry, and claiming the best spot is not a huge feat.

The advantage of Cricket is that you can visit their Wireless Stores, which are available in many locations across the country. You can also sign up online and talk to their customer service reps.

The benefit of going for the online option is that you won’t be charged the $25 fee that the store reps will charge you.

Phones and Devices Supported

Best TracFone Phones

TracFone goes a long way to offer you affordable services, but are they up to date with the devices that support their plans? No. They do not provide the latest smartphones. The advantage of this is that they have low-cost phones; however, not everyone wants them.

The downside of this is that obsolescence is a huge concern, owing to how the smartphone industry is fast-paced. Spending money on a phone that has already been in the market for a couple of years means that you won’t be getting any critical updates in a few years.

The good is that you are not limited to their rather, dismal, collection of phones. There is a Bring Your Own Phone option that supports both GSM and CDMA phones. However, this BYOP plan does not suit all models, and always check with their compatibility checker to confirm if yours qualifies for the plan.

Best Cricket Wireless Phones

Cricket has a couple of options for a free smartphone when subscribing to their service. However, you need to port a number to be eligible for the free phones. This is a rather complicated way to go as most people opt for the BYOP feature. Again, you need to ensure that your phone is compatible to their service.

You could be required to get a new SIM card for $10 when using this plan. In addition, you can but Cricket Wireless insurance that covers your phone against any damage. This insurance mostly applies to new phones.

The Good and Bad of TracFone vs Cricket

Pros of TracFone

  • Offers affordable no-contract plans for smartphones and regular cell phones
  • Their network coverage is pretty strong since it relies on five major carriers
  • Cheap international calling
  • Bring your phone option does not limit you to certain cell phone brands

Cons of TracFone

  • Poor customer service
  • Can get costly for people who use a lot of data

Pros of Cricket

  • High quality of service due to AT&Ts robust network
  • Offers top QoS at a lower price than major carrier wireless plans
  • No credit check when switching from another carrier
  • Short term contracts
  • Flat fees for their plans

Cons of Cricket

  • Slow data speeds
  • Limited phone selection

FAQs About Cricket vs TracFone

Is Cricket better than TracFone?

It all goes down to what you want and your mobile phone usage. Cricket is better for someone who does not need to use a lot of data but still desires excellent network performance. If you are always facing issues with your network usage and need helpful customer service, Cricket might be your pick.

Is TracFone a good deal?

TracFone offers a good deal to those that like to text and make calls periodically but not too much. If you are looking for unlimited plans and more than 2GB of data, look at what other MVNOs have to offer.

Is Cricket wireless any good?

Cricket is a reliable wireless provider since it relies on the robust AT&T network. This allows customers to enjoy the perks of using a major carrier while still getting low-cost plans offered by the MVNOs.

Does TracFone have any activation fees?

There are no hidden fees associated with TracFone Wireless.

Verdict on Tracfone vs Cricket

When giving the verdict, we will analyze these two carriers based on what they offer in regards to the top features discussed above.


TracFone provides a lot of options, but unless you do not need the data or extra minutes, the smartphone-based ones are what appear to be the better deal. Lots of competitors offer better plans for those that may require additional minutes and data.

Cricket offers excellent plans that are competitive and provide value. Regardless of whether you want an individual or family plan, there is a high probability that Cricket might your cheapest option out there.


TracFone connects to towers owned by AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile, US Cellular, and Verizon, so their performance is pretty good compared to other MVNOs. However, the network might not be very reliable in rural areas.

Cricket uses AT&T’s network, and the coverage is good, especially if you live in the city. The speeds offered by Cricket are limited and comparatively slow when you put them up against what the competition offers.

Customer Service

This is a big concern for many telecommunication companies, and TracFone is no different. There is a lot to desire in the manner in which their representatives address customer queries. The plus in regards to this is that they are available on social media and you no longer have to wait on the phone for a long time.

Cricket’s customer service is not all that great, but they will be quick to attend to simple issues and questions.

Overall Assessment

TracFone and Cricket are both great MVNOs offering competitive plans at affordable prices.

TracFone is suitable for someone who does not use their phone a lot since their basic plans are cheaper than the competition.

Cricket is a precise and basic plan that gets the job done. It does what is advertised and will get the job done at a low price.

Bottom Line Summary: If you live in an urban area, TracFone presents a good value because it uses the best available cell networks. TracFone is also great if you (or your loved one) only makes periodic calls. A better solution for higher data usage (think other things beside calling, like text, browsing, music) is to go with one the Cricket Plans here. Cricket is a part of the AT&T network, too, so if your area has good AT&T coverage OR you live in a rural area, Cricket tends to have better service than TracFone.

Recommended Reads on Great Cell Options for Seniors:

John Hughes

John Hughes thinks about the future a lot and has a lot of information to share with people. While he might not be a senior yet, he knows it is coming and wants to prepare. Everything he learns, he shares with the readers of Wizer List. Why are you giving advice on Wizer List? We might be young now, but old age is inevitable and it comes with its fair share of challenges. People experience old age differently, with some maintaining good health, proper finances, and thriving lives but it is not always this way. However, navigating through this phase of life is much better for the people and those around them if they have the information needed to improve their lives. This is what motivates me to give advice on Wizerlist as I try to empower seniors and those approaching this stage of life to understand what it takes to lead a comfortable life. What personal experience do you have with senior living? I've grown up with different seniors in my life, and coincidentally they were at extreme ends of the scale. One was thriving while another was not doing very well. As such, this stark contrast was so bare and evident that it prompted me to find out why this was the case yet both of them seemed to lead illustrious lives while they were younger. My little quest made me find out that while they both had the world at their hands while they were younger, a few simple decisions like the best retirement plans, where to retire among others are what led to this massive rift between their lives. If you could give people one piece of advice about living as a senior, what would it be? Prepare for life as a senior from the moment you start working. You might be twenty and think fifty-five is a long time away, but years drift by and before you know it, retirement age will be around the corner. If you have all the means, i.e a good job, and medical plan, plan for retirement. Leverage some long-term investment instruments that will facilitate your comfortable life when you approach retirement. Learn and unlearn as you try to find what works for you.

Leave a Reply