You are currently viewing Medical Guardian vs Life Alert: Which Do You Need More?

Medical Guardian vs Life Alert: Which Do You Need More?

Latest posts by WizerList Team (see all)

Whether you’re a senior citizen or someone with a specific disability, it’s important for you to have access to a reliable means of assistance in the event of an emergency. Thanks to innovative technology and leading medical professionals around the world, you can now gain access to trustworthy medical assistance with the simple click of a button for virtually any medical emergency situation that you may be dealing with.

There are a lot of emergency assistance programs and services you can gain access to in order to help those who are elderly in your family or for those who may need a little extra attention in terms of living with the everyday factors that come with certain medical conditions. With the assistance of one of these services, you no longer have to worry about your disabled or elderly family member being alone when an accident or worse strikes. Although there are several different medical alert and assistance programs and service providers out there, that doesn’t mean that all of them are created equal.

Two of the most widely used and trusted medical alert and assistance platforms out there are Medical Guardian and Life Alert. Both of these services offer a premium medical alert and assistance options for virtually any older person who needs a reliable aid by their side in the event of an emergency situation in which they aren’t able to fix the issue themselves. You don’t have to suffer from a medical condition or disability to enjoy the benefits of either Medical Guardian or Life Alert as they can be really good for anyone who may need just a little bit more help in their everyday lives and activities.

Some of the factors that will determine which medical alert system you use include price, device options, response time, the level of aid the services offer, tracking capabilities, and more. That’s why it’s so important for you to consider all of these variables before making a final decision about which medical alert option is best for you. The functionality required to enact the medical alert services that you need will play a huge role in which one you should select for your specific person in question.

Choosing between whether or not Medical Guardian or Life Alert is the right service for you can be difficult, you need to consider all of the various factors that go into each of these medical alert services before making a final decision. If you’re someone who has been interested in signing up for either Medical Guardian or Life Alert but hasn’t been able to make a final decision you’ve come to the right place.

In this guide, we’re going to go over all of the essential features and capabilities that you’ll get access to when signing up for either Medical Guardian or Life Alert so that you can make an educated decision about which medical alert system is right for your specific needs. We’ll cover all of the various capabilities, features, plan options, and service options offered by both Medical Guardian and Life Alert so that you can know exactly which one is perfect for your intended needs.

Make sure that you read this entire guide in full to fully understand how both of these services work in addition to how they can both help you maintain a level of safety and stability for those in your family who may be older or living with a medical condition.

To begin, we’re going to look at some of the histories behind both Medical Guardian and Life Alert so that you will be able to understand which service will provide you with a more comprehensive experience.

Main Differences Between Medical Guardian vs Life Alert

The Main Differences Between Medical Guardian vs Life Alert are:

  • Medical Guardian can be installed by your own, whereas Life Alert offers an installation option that requires a physical technician
  • Medical Guardian only requires its customers to agree to a 90-day service agreement, whereas Life Alert requires that you sign up for a 3yr service contract.
  • Medical Guardian the service offers a price lock guarantee on all of their emergency service plans, whereas Life Alert offers a mobile app.

History Behind Medical Guardian & Life Alert

MedicalGuardian

Medical guardian was started in 2005 and they offer a variety of premium devices and technology that can assist people who are dealing with medical issues and other symptoms while living on their own. Medical Guardian puts extra focus on its systems monitoring capabilities so you’ll always be covered in the event of an emergency. Medical Guardian employees many well trained, experienced, and knowledgeable operators who will be able to help you get the right assistance that you need no matter how big or small your emergency may be.

Medical Guardian offers 24/7 monitoring and emergency assistance services so that you have all-around coverage in the event that you need immediate assistance for help dealing with an emergency situation. Medical Guardian provides an emergency detection system so that if you happen to fall you will immediately be able to receive assistance.

Life Alert

Life Alert has been in the medical alert industry for 30+yrs and has even gotten approval from the prior U.S. Surgeon General who was C. Everett Koop. Life Alert has the main objective of protecting elderly people and their family members in the event of experiencing a medical emergency in which they do not have access to the proper assistance that they need. Life Alert offers very comprehensive medical alert assistance for all types of situations instead of just falling.

Life Alert offers assistance for situations that involve gas leaks, poison gas leaks, and home invasions. Life Alert also offers fall assistance however they offer the additional monitoring services listed above too. Life Alert is known for their very quick response time and since they’ve been around for such a long time, they have more call center agents than most of the other medical alert companies out there.

Life Alert is also known for staying on the line until you receive the proper assistance that you need which is not something that a lot of other medical alert companies offer.

Now that we’ve gone over some of the histories behind both Medical Guardian and Life Alert, it’s time to look at some of the core differences between each company so that you can decide on which medical alert service is right for your particular needs.

Main Comparison: Medical Guardian Vs. Life Alert

Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert come with varying levels of capabilities and alert systems which will help anyone dealing with serious medical conditions or issues get the right help that they need to gain access to medical professionals and emergency response services when they need them for virtually any emergency situation that they may face. Before signing up for either of these services, it’s important for you to consider the specific needs of the individual who has health issues or problems to ensure that you’re choosing the right medical alert service that will provide them with the level of assistance that they need in order to solve any emergency situation that they might experience.

In the following section, we’re going to go over some of the key differences between Medical Guardian and Life Alert in order to give you a better view of exactly how each service differs from one another so you can make an educated decision about which medical alert service will provide you with the most benefit.

Medical Guardian Breakdown

  • Price- $29.95-$49.95/mo.
  • Upfront Expenses- None
  • Contract Required- None
  • Return Policy- Standard
  • Product Options- in-home cellular, GPS+ cellular, smartwatch, in-home traditional
  • Battery Life of Products- 24hrs
  • In-home Range- 1,300 Feet
  • Waterproof Capabilities- Yes
  • Fall Detection- Extra $10/mo.
  • GPS Add-on- Yes
  • Smart Watch- $99 + $44.95/mo.
  • Spouse Monitoring- $2/mo. extra

Life Alert Breakdown

  • Price- $49.95-$89.95/mo.
  • Upfront Expenses- Yes- variable depending on the situation
  • Contract Required- Yes
  • Return Policy- Strict
  • Product Options- mobile + GPS, cellular in-home, Landline
  • Battery Life of Products- 10yrs
  • In-home Range- 800 Feet
  • Waterproof Capabilities- Yes
  • Fall Detection- Comes with the standard plan
  • GPS Add-on- Yes
  • SmartWatch- No
  • Spouse Monitoring- $49 one-time fee

As you can see from the breakdown above, both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer a wide array of very useful and helpful features that can help anyone dealing with a medical issue find the right type of assistance that they need. Before deciding on which service, you want to go with, you should consider the type of medical condition that the person is suffering from, how much assistance they will need in the event of an emergency, how much you’re willing to pay for the service, and the type of equipment that will be most beneficial in terms of providing assistance to the person that is in need of help.

Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer very intuitive medical assistance and alert systems that can be used for any type of medical condition or problem that an individual may be living with. By taking a look at all of the features mentioned above, you’ll be able to select the right medical alert service for your particular needs in no time.

Now that we’ve gone over the main benefits and service options offered by both Medical Guardian and Life Alert, it’s time to look at some of the key differences and similarities between Medical Guardian and Life Alert so that you can get a clear view about which medical alert service will be perfect for you.

Differences & Similarities: Medical Guardian vs. Life Alert

Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer a lot of the same features however there are some small differences which make each service drastically different from the other one. Before making a final decision about which medical alert service is right for you or your family member, it’s important for you to know about all of these various differences and similarities so that you can make an educated decision about which medical alert service offers the complete package you need in terms of reliability, response times, device options, and much more.

We’re going to give you a comprehensive breakdown of all of the differences and similarities between both Medical Guardian and Life Alert so that you will be able to understand which service offers the level of assistance that you’ll need in the event of an emergency. Make sure that you read each part of this section in full to understand the key differences and similarities between each service before signing up for the one that you feel is right for you.

Differences Between Medical Guardian & Life Alert

The core differences that you’ll find between Medical Guardian and life Alert are the method of installation used and the pricing options when it comes to choosing specific plans. Life Alert offers an installation option that requires a physical Life Alert technician to be present during the initial stages of the system set-up.

With Medical Guardian, you can activate and begin using the services solely on your own without the need for a professional service installation tech to help you. Life Alert’s installation process requires a mandatory $96.00-$200.00 fee which you don’t have an option of opting out of. Medical Guardian, on the other hand, does not require that you pay an installation fee and they do not charge any extra fees for the equipment itself, installation, or activation which is why some people prefer their service model over that of Life Alert’s.

Another one of the main differences between Life Alert and Medical Guardian is the contract length requirement. Life Alert requires that you sign up for a 3yr service contract whereas Medical Guardian only requires their customers to agree to a 90-day service agreement. These two options differ greatly and many people do not like the idea of having to be locked into a 3yr agreement because they want the ability to cancel the service if it does not meet their needs without having to pay a cancellation fee.

Medical Guardian, on the other hand, offers a 90-day contract which just basically means that they would like you to use the service for at least 90 days without any responsibilities or obligations so if after 90 days you don’t like the service, you can simply cancel the service without being responsible for paying any cancellation fees or other related service charges. Another main selling point for people who choose Medical Guardian over Life Alert is the fact that the service offers a price lock guarantee on all of their emergency service plans which is something that you won’t find with Life Alert medical alert systems.

One of the advantages that Life Alert has over Medical Guardian, however, is the fact that they offer a mobile app that you can use in order to alert any emergency response teams in the event that you need medical assistance.

Similarities Between Medical Guardian & Life Alert

Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer very advanced medical alert systems and technology that is very responsive and accurate in terms of the amount of time that it takes for professional assistance to arrive and how well the machines can detect accidents or other issues on their own. Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer waterproof capabilities for at-home use and away from home use so that you’re never without the type of assistance that you require for any particular medical condition that you may be dealing with. Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer multiple languages so that regardless of what language you speak, you can always get the proper medical assistance that you need. Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer two-way communication abilities with every single one of their medical alert devices so you can always have access to a physical person when you need help in a particular situation.

Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer fall detection with their various equipment options and package services. By Medical Guardian and Life Alert also offer 24hr monitoring services that are carried out by certified and trained emergency assistance professionals who have the knowledge to help you out in the event of any emergency situation. Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert will send texts and phone calls to those listed contacts in your emergency contact list so that medical professionals will not be the only ones responding to your emergency needs.

Now that you know more about the key differences and similarities between Medical Guardian and life Alert, it’s time to look at an overall view and comparisons between Medical Guardian and Life Alert so that you can choose which medical alert service is perfect for your specific needs.

Main Comparison: Medical Guardian Vs. Life Alert

Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer a wide variety of different medical alert devices and equipment for you to choose from however they differ drastically. The same thing can be said about many other areas of both of these services which is why it’s important for you to do your proper amount of research before making a final decision about which Medical Alert service is right for you. in order for you to get a much better understanding and knowledgebase about both of these medical alert services, we’re going to provide you with a full comparison and explanation of every aspect and feature option that you’ll gain access to when selecting either Medical Guardian or Life Alert as your selected medical alert system and emergency assistance provider.

Contract Lengths

When using any medical alert service, one of the most important things to consider is knowing how long you’ll have access to the emergency assistance that you need in addition to in what capacity you’ll have access to said services. With Life Alert, a 3yr contract is required in order to activate your emergency alert services however Medical Guardian does not require any pre-instated contract length or required service contract except a 90-day service agreement which is required before any medical alert emergency assistance services are activated. This makes it easy for you to cancel the services whenever you want as opposed to Life Alert where a 3yrs contract is required in order for you to use the services at all and there are also several cancellation fees applied to your account in the event that you terminate a contract before the allotted amount of time.

Features

One of the most important things to consider when selecting which medical alert system is right for you is the type of emergency alert equipment that you will have access to. Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer a variety of different emergency equipment options and accessories that you can choose from in order to receive the proper assistance you need when it comes to responding to any emergency that you may have.

Life Alert offers more robust options when it comes to medical alert accessors and equipment because they offer things such as shower/hallway buttons, pendants, and wristband for in-home protection against any potential accidents or medical emergencies. Life Alert also gives you the ability to add additional services to your plan including home intrusion detection and fall detection for those who need more monitoring and emergency response assistance.

With Life Alert, you also have the ability to use their Mobile App when you’re not at home or you can ask them about their cell phone option which is also great for those living with medical conditions and wander outside of the home frequently. Medical Guardian on the other hands offers clip-on, pendant, and wristband options for those who need extra support in the event of an emergency situation. Medical Guardian also offers emergency response equipment that is waterproof and offers two-way communication abilities so that you can always speak with another individual who is really on the other end instead of talking to an automated system.

Medical Guardian also offers a Lockbox service and medical history card which allows emergency responders to get your necessary information in the event of an issue without having to break into your home to gain access to the help that you need. Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offers devices that have a range of about 1,300 feet which is more than enough for any regular-sized home.

Pricing

Life Alert offers a lot of different plan options all of which vary in terms of their pricing and the capabilities that you will get access to. Life Alert offers a basic plan which starts at about $50/mo. and their pricing plans go as high as $90/mo. The additional fall detection and home intrusion capabilities are add-ons that can be added to any Life Alert package you select.

To activate your Life Alert services, you have to pay an approximate $96 to $200 installation fee which will allow you to begin using the emergency service request that you need at any given moment. Medical Guardian, on the other hand, offers a slew of different emergency response plans which include their Medical Guardian Classic plan which starts at $29.95/mo., the Medical Guardian Home Guardian plan starts at #34.95/mo., the Medical Guardian Active Guardian plan is $49.95/mo., the Medical Guardian Mobile Guardian plan is $39.95/mo., and Medical Guardian also offers a family plan for about $80.00/mo.

Connectivity

Life Alert works by using a completely wireless system and all of the emergency services are operated on a Mobile Network which provides ultimate reliability and a stable connection under any circumstances. Medical Guardian offers and emergency response system that operates solely on a landline connection however you can switch to cellular network operation if you choose to do so.

Response Times

Medical Guardian offers Five Diamond Certified call centers and they offer response times of about 45 secs. Life Alert also offers Five Diamond Certified call centers that provide response times of about 15 to 20 secs so they are much faster and more experienced than Medical Guardian in terms of how fast they will be able to respond to your particular emergency situation.

Medical Guardian Vs. Life Alert: Pros & Cons

Medical Guardian

Pros

  • Various different plans that you can choose from to get the perfect emergency assistance help that you need.
  • Different equipment types that you can use which will offer different monitoring capabilities.
  • No contract required to begin service only a 90-day service contract.
  • No installation fees are required to begin activating your emergency alert system services

Cons

  • Landline functionality which may be more unreliable than some wireless options.
  • Slower response times than Life Alert emergency response systems.

Life Alert

Pros

  • Wireless base station which allows you to maintain a stable and reliable connection at all times.
  • Two-way communication tools so that you always have access to a real person when you’re in an emergency situation.
  • Fall detection and home intrusion add-on capabilities for extra security and protection.
  • Experienced call center technicians and professionals who can assist you in any situation with quality guaranteed.
  • Various emergency response equipment options for you to choose from in order to make sure you have access to the exact type of help that you need.
  • Very fast response times and mobile app so that you can get emergency assistance even when you’re not at home.

Cons

  • Installation fee required to activate service
  • 3yrs contract required to begin using the service and cancellation fees are applied

Medical Guardian Vs. Life Alert: Which One Is Right for You?

Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer very comprehensive medical alert programs and systems which will allow you to get the assistance you need in the event of a medical emergency. Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert come with varying levels of capabilities and alert systems which will help anyone dealing with serious medical conditions or issues get the right help that they need in order to gain access to medical professionals and emergency response services when they need them for virtually any emergency situation that they may face.

Before signing up for either of these services, it’s important for you to consider the specific needs of the individual who has health issues or problems to ensure that you’re choosing the right medical alert service that will provide them with the level of assistance that they need in order to solve any emergency situation that they might experience.

The core differences that you’ll find between Medical Guardian and life Alert are the method of installation used and the pricing options when it comes to choosing specific plans. Life Alert offers an installation option that requires a physical Life Alert technician to be present during the initial stages of the system set-up. With Medical Guardian, you have the ability to activate and begin using the services solely on your own without the need for a professional service installation tech to help you.

One of the most important things to consider when selecting which medical alert system is right for you is the type of emergency alert equipment that you will have access to. Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer a variety of different emergency equipment options and accessories that you can choose from in order to receive the proper assistance you need when it comes to responding to any emergency that you may have.

Life Alert offers more robust options when it comes to medical alert accessors and equipment because they offer things such as shower/hallway buttons, pendants, and wristband for in-home protection against any potential accidents or medical emergencies. Life Alert also gives you the ability to add additional services to your plan including home intrusion detection and fall detection for those who need more monitoring and emergency response assistance.

Life Alert’s installation process requires a mandatory $96.00-$200.00 fees which you don’t have an option of opting out of. Medical Guardian, on the other hand, does not require that you pay an installation fee and they do not charge any extra fees for the equipment itself, installation, or activation which is why some people prefer their service model over that of Life Alert’s.

Another one of the main differences between Life Alert and Medical Guardian is the contract length requirement. Life Alert requires that you sign up for a 3yr service contract whereas Medical Guardian only requires their customers to agree to a 90-day service agreement.

Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer a lot of the same features however there are some small differences which make each service drastically different from the other one. Before making a final decision about which medical alert service is right for you or your family member, it’s important for you to know about all of these various differences and similarities so that you can make an educated decision about which medical alert service offers the complete package you need in terms of reliability, response times, device options, and much more.

These two options differ greatly and many people do not like the idea of having to be locked into a 3yr agreement because they want the ability to cancel the service if it does not meet their needs without having to pay a cancellation fee. Medical Guardian, on the other hand, offers a 90-day contract which just basically means that they would like you to use the service for at least 90 days without any responsibilities or obligations so if after 90 days you don’t like the service, you can simply cancel the service without being responsible for paying any cancellation fees or other related service charges.

While both services also essentially the same type of assistance, they do offer vary significantly depending on your specific needs. Another main selling point for people who choose Medical Guardian over Life Alert is the fact that the service offers a price lock guarantee on all of their emergency service plans which is something that you won’t find with Life Alert medical alert systems. One of the advantages that Life Alert has over Medical Guardian, however, is the fact that they offer a mobile app that you can use in order to alert any emergency response teams in the event that you need medical assistance.

Conclusion

We’ve covered all of the most important aspects and features that you need to know as it relates to the main differences and similarities between both Life Alert and Medical Guardian. By reading this entire guide in full, you’ll be able to clearly distinguish between all of the features and capabilities that you need to have access to the most and which ones aren’t so important to you.

Both Medical Guardian and Life Alert offer very well-respected and trusted medical emergency response services that you can call on in the event of nearly any type of medical emergency situation that you may be dealing with. Always consider your specific needs and individual health issues before deciding on which service provider is right for you so that you can be sure you’re making the right decision about which medical alert system will provide you with the most benefits.

As long as you take into consideration all of the tips and information we’ve covered in this guide, you should have no problem making the right decision about which medical alert system provides the reliability, response time, experience, and versatility that you need most.

WizerList Team

Our team at WizerList understands that there is a new set of challenges when you become early. There are more tools you need to help you live and move without trouble. We're here to help you.

Leave a Reply